Paper title:
  The Entente’s Second Inter-Union Mission under the Chairmanship of Joseph Barthélemy (February 20 – March 3, 1919)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.4316/CC.2021.02.002
Published in:
Issue 2 (Vol. 27) / 2021
Publishing date:
2021-12-31
Pages:
 331-354
Author(s):
 Yevhen Lyzen, Volodymyr Komar, Ihor Soliar
Abstract:
 The article examines the activities of the second Entente peacekeeping mission in Eastern Galicia under French General Joseph Barthélemy, analyses the reasons for its establishment and highlights the consequences of its diplomatic efforts for both sides of the Polish-Ukrainian armed conflict of 1918–1919. It was proved that, in addition to their formal duties, the mission members were given important instructions on how further to penetrate and, subsequently, to strengthen the Entente’s positions in the Galician region. Furthermore, the aim was to devise counter-measures to the revolutionary movement and socialist ideas in the newly created states of Eastern Europe. Its equally crucial purpose was to investigate the circumstances surrounding the Polish-Ukrainian conflict and examine the prospect of using Polish and Ukrainian troops in the fight against Bolshevik Russia. Despite the informative nature of the mission, its members began negotiations with Ukrainians and Poles in January, but the talks did not result in a real ceasefire around Lviv. It should be highlighted that Joseph Barthélemy’s mission did not only fail to reconcile the parties involved in the war but rather incited them to fight each other. At the same time, it promised the Ukrainians the political support of the Entente and the Poles – the Drohobych-Boryslav basin, which was under Ukrainian control. With such recommendations, it was clear that a truce was unlikely. Not wanting to lose rich oil lands that were a substantial source of income, the State Secretariat of the Western Ukrainian People’s Republic refused to agree to the demarcation line proposed by Joseph Barthélemy unconditionally.
Keywords:
 Peacekeeping mission, Joseph Barthélemy, Western Ukrainian People’s Republic, Poland, Entente, Eastern Galicia.




References:
 1. Adadurov Vadym, Polityka Frantsii stosovno ukrainsko-polskoho konfliktu za Skhidnu Halychynu v period z lystopada 1918 po berezen 1919 rr. [French Policy on the Ukrainian-Polish Conflict over Eastern Galicia in the Period from November 1918 to March 1919], in Ukraina v mynulomu [Ukraine in the Past], Kyiv, Lviv, 1995, Vol. 7, s. 18-32.
2. Avram Valeriu, Drăghici Lucian, Pătraşcu Gabriel-George, Rîşnoveanu Ion, Războiul de Întregire (1916-1919). Comandanţi militari români [War of Integration (1916-1919). Romanian Military Commanders], Bucureşti, Editura Centrului Tehnic-Editorial al Armatei, 2016, 320 p.
3. Borchuk Stepan, Korolko Andrii, Reient Aleksandr, Accession of part of Eastern Galicia to Romania in 1919: military and political aspects, in “Codrul Cosminului”, 2020, vol. 26, no. 1, p. 169-187, https://doi.org/10.4316/CC.2020.01.010
4. Carton de Wiart Adrian, Happy Odyssey. The Memoirs of Lieutenant–General Sir Adrian Carton de Wiart, London, Jonathan Cape, 1950, 287 p.
5. Davies Norman, Polish national mythologies, in Geoffrey Hosking, George Schöpflin (Eds.), Myths and Nationhood, New York, Routledge, 1997, p. 141–157.
6. Fahn Ruben, Istoriia Yevreiskoi natsionalnoi avtonomii v period Zakhidno-Ukrainskoi Respubliky [History of Jewish National Autonomy in the Period of the Western Ukrainian Republic], Lviv, 2019, 272 s.
7. Galuba Rafał, „Niech nas rozsądzi miecz i krew”. Konflikt polsko–ukraiński o Galicję Wschodnią w latach 1918–1919 [“Let us be judged by sword and blood.” The Polish-Ukrainian conflict over Eastern Galicia in 1918–1919], Poznań, Wydawnictwo Poznańskie, 2004, 335 p.
8. Grange Cyril, Les classes privilégiées dans l’espace parisien (1903–1987) [The Privi-leged Classes in the Parisian Area (1903–1987)], in “Espace, Populations, Sociétés”, 1993, No. 1, p. 11–21.
9. Hunczak Taras (ed.), Ukraine and Poland in Documents. 1918 – 1922. Part I, New York, Paris, Sydney, Toronto, 1983, 456 p.
10. Isaievych Yaroslav, Lytvyn Mykola, Pater Ivan, Soliar Ihor (Eds.), Zakhidno-Ukrain-ska narodna respublika. 1918–1923. Uriady. Postati [Western Ukrainian Peoples Republic. 1918–1923. Governments. Famous figures], Lviv, 2009, 350 s.
11. Kamiński Marek Kazimierz, Konflikt polsko-czeski 1918-1921 [Polish-Czech conflict 1918-1921], Warszawa, Neriton, 2001, 476 p.
12. Karpenko Oleksandr (red.), Zakhidno-Ukrainska Narodna Respublika. 1918 – 1923. Istoriia [Western Ukrainian Peoples Republic. 1918 – 1923. History], Ivano-Frankivsk, 2001, 628 s.
13. Karpenko Oleksandr, Mytsan Kateryna (com.), Zakhidno-Ukrainska Narodna Res-publika 1918–1923. Dokumenty i materialy: u 5-kh tomakh [West Ukrainian Peoples Republic 1918–1923. Documents and Materials: in 5 volumes], Ivano-Frankivsk, 2009, Vol. 5 (1), Zovnishnia polityka i mizhnarodne stanovyshche. 1918–1919 rr. [Foreign Policy and International Situation. 1918–1919].
14. Karpynets Ivan, Istoriia 8-oi Halytskoi bryhady [History of the 8th Galician Brigade], in Litopys “Chervonoi Kalyny” [Chronicle of the "Red Viburnum"], Lviv, 1933, no. 7-8, s. 33-34.
15. Klimecki Michał, Polsko-ukraińska wojna o wschodnią Galicję 1918-1919 r. Polskie spojrzenie [Polish-Ukrainian War for Eastern Galicia 1918-1919. Polish View], in “Ukraina: kulturna spadshchyna, natsionalna svidomist, der¬zhav-nist” [Ukraine: Cultural Heritage, National Consciousness, Statehood], 2009, no. 18, s. 373-384.
16. Klymchuk Oleksandr (ed.), Symon Vasylovych Petliura. Statti [Symon Vasylovych Petliura. Articles], Kyiv, 1993.
17. Korolko Andrii, Rumunska okupatsiia Pokuttia i Halytskoi Hutsulshchyny (traven – serpen 1919 r.): peredumovy, perebih, naslidky [Romanian Occupation of Pokutia and Galician Gutsulshchyna (May-August 1919): Background, Course, Consequences], in “Naukovyi chasopys Natsionalnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni M. P. Drahomanova. Seriia Istorychni nauky” [Scientific Journal of National Pedagogical Dragomanov University. Historical Sciences], 2016, Vol. 14, s. 195-210.
18. Kozłowski Maciej, Między Sanem a Zbruczem. Walki o Lwów i Galicję Wschodnią, 1918 – 1919 [Between the Rivers Sian and Zbruch. Battles for Lviv and Eastern Galicia, 1918 – 1919], Krakow, 1990. 311 s.
19. Krasivskyi Orest, Halychyna v pershii chverti ХХ st.: Problemy polsko-ukrainskykh vidnosyn [Galicia in the First Quarter of the 20th Century: Problems of Polish-Ukrainian Relations], Lviv, 2000, 416 s.
20. Kuchabskyi Vasyl, Zakhidna Ukraina u borotbi z Polshcheiu ta bilshovyzmom u 1918 – 1923 rokakh [Western Ukraine in Conflict with Poland and Bolshevism, 1918–1923], Lviv, 2005, 448 s.
21. Lozynskyi Mykhalo, Halychyna na Myrovii konferentsii v Paryzhi [Galicia at the Peace Conference in Paris], Kamianets-Podilskyi, 1919, 31 s.
22. Lozynskyi Mykhalo, Halychyna v pp. 1918 – 1920 [Galicia in the Years 1918 – 1920], Viden, 1922, 228 s.
23. Lysiak-Rudnytskyi Ivan, Polsko-ukrainski stosunky. Tiahar istorii [Polish-Ukrainian Relations. The Burden of History], in Istorychni ese. V 2 t. [Historical Essays. In Two Volumes], Kyiv, 1994, vol. 1, s. 83–111.
24. Lytvyn Mykola, Naumenko Kim, Istoriia halytskoho striletstva [History of Galician Shooters], Lviv, 1991, 198 s.
25. Lytvyn Mykola, Ukrainsko-polska viina 1918-1919 [Ukrainian-Polish War 1918-1919], Lviv, 1998, 488 s.
26. Lyzen Yevhen, Diialnist myrotvorchoi misii J. Barthélemy u vrehuliuvanni polsko-ukrainskoho viiskovoho konfliktu u liutomu–berezni 1919 r. [The Activity of the Peaceful Mission by Joseph Barthélemy in the Resolution the Polish-Ukrainian Armed Conflict of the February-March of 1919], in “Vcheni zapysky Tavriiskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni V. I. Vernadskoho. Seriia: Istorychni nauky” [Scientific Notes of Tavriya National University Named after Vl. Vernadsky. Series: Historical Sciences], 2019, Tom 30 (69), № 2, s. 130–134.
27. Lyzen Yevhen, Diialnist myrotvorchoy misii J. Barthélemy v pratsiakh M. Lozynskoho [Activities of J. Barthélemy's Peacekeeping Mission in the Works of M. Lozynsky], in “Materialy Mizhnarodnoi naukovoi konferentsii do 100-richchia utvorennia Zakhidno-Ukrainskoi Narodnoi Respubliky. Halychyna. Naukovyi i kulturno-prosvitnii kraieznavchyi chasopys” [Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference Dedicated to the 100th Anniversary of the Formation of the Western Ukrainian People's Republic. Galicia. Scientific and cultural-educational local lore journal], 2019, No. 32, s. 226–232.
28. Lyzen Yevhen, Persha misiia Antanty pid kerivnytstvom J. Barthélemy (25 sichnia – 11 liutoho 1919 r.) [The First Mission of the Entente Under the Leadership of J. Barthélemy (January 25 - February 11, 1919)], in “Naukovyi visnyk Uzhhorodskoho universytetu. Seriia: Istoriia” [Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod University. Series: History], 2020, No. 2 (43), s. 130–137.
29. Makarchuk Stepan, Ukrainska respublika halychan [Ukrainian Republic of Galician Ukrainians], Lviv, 1997, 192 s.
30. Mihout Мylène, Les capitaux nordistes en quête de nouveaux horizons : « le groupe pétrolier du Nord » & le pétrole galicien (1911–1928) [Northern Capital in Search of New Horizons: “The Northern Oil Group” & Galician Oil (1911–1928)], in “Revue du Nord”, 1993, tome 75, No. 300, p. 421–441.
31. Murat Daniel, L’Intervention de l’État dans le secteur pétrolier en France [State Inter-vention in the Oil Sector in France], Paris, Edition Technip, 1969, 331 р.
32. Omelianovych-Pavlenko Mykhailo, Spohady ukrainskoho komandarma. Na Ukraini, 1918-1920. Ukrainsko-polska viina. Na Ukraini, 1919. Zymovyi pokhid, 1920 [Memoirs of a Ukrainian Commander. In Ukraine, 1918-1920. Ukrainian-Polish War. In Ukraine, 1919. Winter Campaign, 1920], Кyiv, 2002, 460 s.
33. Omelianovych-Pavlenko Mykhailo, Ukrainsko-polska viina 1918 – 1919 [The Ukrainian-Polish War of 1918–19], Praha, 1929, 72 с.
34. Preda Dumitru, Alexandrescu Vasile, Prodan Costică, Īn apărarea României Mari. Campania armatei române din 1918–1919 [In Defense of Greater Romania. The Campaign of the Romanian Army from 1918-1919], Bucureşti, Editura Enciclopedică, 1994, 336 p.
35. Prizel Іlya, National Identity and Foreign Policy: Nationalism and Leadership in Poland, Russia and Ukraine, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1998, 443 p.
36. Shankovskyi Lev, Ukrainska Halytska Armiia: voienno-istorychna studiia [Ukrainian Army of Galicia: a Study in Military History], Vinnipeh, 1974, 396 s.
37. Thompson M. John, Russia, Bolshevism, and the Versailles Peace, New Jersey, Prince-ton University Press, 1967, 438 p.
38. Tychka Hanna-Melania, Skhidna Halychyna u politytsi Frantsii (1918–1919): dys. kand. ist. nauk [Eastern Galicia in the Politics of France (1918–1919): dis. cand. of hist. sciences], Lviv, 2018.
39. Tymchenko Roman, Vidnosyny Ukrainskoi Narodnoi Respubliky i Zakhidno-Ukrain-skoi Narodnoi Respubliky (lystopad 1918 – kviten 1920 rr.) [Relations between the Ukrainian Peoples Republic and the Western Ukrainian Peoples Republic (November 1918 – April 1920)], Kyiv, 2013, 347 s.
40. Tyshchyk Borys, Zakhidno-Ukrainska Narodna Respublika (1918 – 1923): Istoriia derzhavy i prava [Western Ukrainian Peoples Republic (1918 – 1923): History of State and Law], Lviv, 2004, 392 s.
41. Yaroslavyn Sydir, Vyzvolna borotba na Zakhidno-ukrainskykh zemliakh u 1918 – 1923 rr. [The Liberation Struggle in the Western Ukrainian Lands in 1918 – 1923], Filadelfia, 1956, 182 s.
42. Yosypyshyna Yaroslav, Symon Petliura: Polshcha y Antanta. U 70-richchia trahedii 1926−1996: zb. materialiv pro vidznachennia 70-richchia zahybeli Symona Petliury [Symon Petliura: Poland and the Entente. To the 70th anniversary of the tragedy of 1926-1996: Collection of materials for the celebration of the 70th anniversary of the death of Symon Petliura], Kyiv, 1997.