Paper title:
  Extremes and Exceptions: Civilian Attitudes toward Jews in Bukovina during World War II
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.4316/CC.2020.01.007
Published in:
Issue 1 (Vol. 26) / 2020
Publishing date:
2020-07-31
Pages:
 93-112
Author(s):
 Stefan Purici, Harieta Mareci-Sabol
Abstract:
 The pre-war political and social atmosphere, the subsequent regulations imposed by authorities, interests or circumstances, the international context, and the moral principles motivated – together or in part – some of the decisions and actions against the Jews of Bukovina. The authors of this article raise a few questions: When and in what con¬text did the violence occur? Where did the violence happen? Why did people do that? The organization of information in order to obtain the answers contributes to highlighting the responsibility of the actors of the time, other than the army: civilian authorities, the popula¬tion of towns and villages in Bukovina. Usually, attacks, robberies and murders are most often cited in historical analysis. They were the result of instigations and challenges, some organized at the state level, some manifesting themselves as "improvisations" of the locals. Moreover, the “social field” of violence was systematically prepared in the interwar period, the ideology of right-wing radicalism and anti-Semitism entering the Romanian society, amid economic difficulties. In addition, the fear of being punished by the military authorities (who coordinated the arrest, deportation and guarding of Jews) is a basic explanation to justify avoiding mutual contact between the Jews and non-Jews. As for non-Jews civilian's solidarity, charity and support, they are less analyzed in the historiography of the problem. That is why their knowledge becomes extremely important, as long as these examples illustrating not only the acts of resistance against government actions but also the human decency and absolute, uncompromising respect for the values of humanity.
Keywords:
 Jews, Bukovina, anti-Semitism, World War II, civilian, violence, persecution, solidarity, humanity.




References:
 1. Ancel Jean, The History of the Holocaust in Romania, Lincoln, University of Nebraska Press; Jerusalem, Yad Vashem, 2011, 699 p.
2. Arthur Klinghoffer, in Verlorene Kindheit. Copilărie pierdută, Projektgruppe "Kriegsgräber", 2017, p. 51-61, http://www.rsg-roev.de/europaschule/dateien/pdf/kg_verloreneKindheit2017.pdf
3. Beck Oskar, Bukowina: Schweiz des Ostens?, "Der Südostdeutsche", München, 15 März 1978, S. 5.
4. Benjamin Lya (Ed.), Problema evreiască în stenogramele Consiliului de Miniștri [The Jewish Problem in the Records of the Council of Ministers], Vol. II, București, Editura Hasefer, 1996, 623 p.
5. Benjamin Lya, Stanciu Sergiu (Eds.), Evreii din România între anii 1940-1944: Izvoare și mărturisiri referitoare la evreii din România [The Jews of Romania during 1940-1944: Sources and confessions regarding the Jews in Romania], Vol. I, București, Editura Hasefer, 1993, 488 p.
6. Bergen Doris L., Rivalry, Indifference or Solidarity? Jews and `Other Victims' in Studies of the Holocaust and Comparative Genocide, in John K. Roth, Elisabeth Maxwell, Margot Levy, Wendy Whitworth (Eds.), Remembering for the Future. The Holocaust in an Age of Genocide, Vol. 1, History, New York, Palgrave, 2001, p. 29-42.
7. Carp Matatias, Cartea neagră. Fapte și documente. Suferințele evreilor din România, 1940-1944 [Black Book: Facts and Documents. The Sufferings of the Jews of Romania, 1940-1944], București, Libraria Socec Co., Vol. I, 1946, 380 p; Vol. II, 1948, 191 p.; Vol III, 1947, 476 p.
8. Cărare Liviu, Considerații privind ghetoizarea evreilor din Cernăuți (1941) [Considerations on the Chernivtsi Jews process of ghettoization (1941)], in "Anuarul Institutului de Istorie George Barițiu", Series Historica, 2010, Vol. XLIX, p. 99-107.
9. Cărare Liviu, Deportările din Cernăuți (1941). Mărturii pe baza unui raport de anchetă informativă [Deportations from Chernivtsi (1941). Testimonies based on an informative investigation report], in Vasile Ciobanu, Sorin Radu (Eds.), Partide politice și minorități naționale din România în secolul XX [Political parties and national minorities in Romania in the twentieth century], Vol. V, Sibiu, Editura Techno Media, 2010, p. 247-255.
10. Cremers Hartwig, Czernowitz 1941/1942 - der Einsatz des deutschen Konsuls Fritz Schellhorn für die Juden, in "Sudost-Forschungen", Band 73, 2014, S. 450-457.
11. Deletant Dennis, Hitler's Forgotten Ally. Ion Antonescu and his regime, Romania 1940-44, Palgrave Macmillan, 2006, 379 p.
12. Dumitru Diana, The State, Antisemitism, and Collaboration in the Holocaust: The Borderlands of Romania and the Soviet Union, Cambridge University Press, 2016, 268 p.
13. Dumitru Diana, Johnson Carter, Constructing Interethnic Conflict and Cooperation. Why Some People Harmed Jews and Others Helped Them during the Holocaust in Romania, in "World Politics", Vol. 63, 2011, No. 1, p. 1-42.
14. Eitan Shalom, Să supraviețuiești, pentru ca să povestești! [To survive to tell the story], Boian, 2005, 109 p. http://www.mareleboian.com/wp-content/uploads/Shalom-Eitan-Sa-supravetuiesti-ca-sa-povestesti.pdf
15. Erika Feiler, geb. Weinstein, in Verlorene Kindheit. Copilărie pierdută, Projektgruppe "Kriegsgräber", 2017, pp. 71-99, http://www.rsg-roev.de/europaschule/dateien/pdf/kg_verloreneKindheit2017.pdf
16. Fisher Gaëlle, Between Liberation and Emigration: Jews from Bukovina in Romania after the Second World War, in "Leo Baeck Institute Year Book", Vol. 62, 2017, p. 115-132.
17. Fisher Gaëlle, New Research on the Holocaust in Romania, in "Sehepunkte", 2018, No. 3, http://www.sehepunkte.de/2018/03/30622.html
18. Friling Tuvia, Ioanid Radu, Ionescu Mihail E., (Eds.), Final Report, International Comission on the Holocaust in Romania, Iași, Editura Polirom, 2004, 415 p.
19. Gallant Mary J., Social Dimensions of Rescue in the Holocaust, in John K. Roth, Elisabeth Maxwell, Margot Levy, Wendy Whitworth (Eds.), Remembering for the Future. The Holocaust in an Age of Genocide, Vol. 2, Ethics and Religion, New York, Palgrave, 2001, p. 254-270.
20. Geissbühler Simon, "He spoke Yiddish like a Jew": Neighbors' Contribution to the Mass Killing of Jews in Northern Bukovina and Bessarabia, July 1941, "Holocaust and Genocide Studies", Vol. 28, 2014, No. 3, p. 430-449.
21. Hausleitner Mariana, Acțiunile de salvare a evreilor prigoniți, în special în Bucovina, 1941-1944 [The rescue actions for persecuted Jews, especially in Bukovina, 1941-1944], in Wolfgang Benz, Brigitte Mihok (Eds.), Holocaustul la periferie. Persecutarea și nimicirea evreilor în România și Transnistria în 1940-1944 [Holocaust at the Periphery: Persecution and destruction of the Jews in Romania and Transnistria in 1940-1944], Chișinău, Editura Cartier, 2010, p. 173-198.
22. Heinen Armin, Rumänien, der Holocaust und die Logik der Gewalt, München, Oldenbourg Verlag, 2007, 208 p.
23. Heymann Florence, Le Crépuscule des lieux : Identités juives de Czernowitz, Paris, Stock, 2003, 442 p.
24. Hirsch Marianne, Spitzer Leo, Ghosts of Home: The Afterlife of Czernowitz in Jewish Memory, Berkeley, University of California Press, 2009, 362 p.
25. Hirsch Marianne, Spitzer Leo, The Cernăuți Ghetto, the Deportations, and the Decent Mayor, in Valentina Glajar, Jeanine Teodorescu (Eds.), Local history, transnational memory in the Romanian Holocaust, New York, Palgrave Macmillan, 2011, p. 57-76.
26. Hrenciuc Daniel, Dilemele conviețuirii: evreii în Bucovina (1774-1947) [The Dilemmas of Coexistence: Jews in Bukovina], Iași, Editura Pim, 2013, 632 p.
27. Interviu Ietti Leibovici [Interview Ietti Leibovici], Institutul Național pentru Studierea Holocaustului din România "Elie Wiesel", http://www.inshr-ew.ro/ro/marturii/222-interviu-ietti-leibovici.html
28. Interviu Miriam Korber-Bercovici [Interview Miriam Korber-Bercovici], Institutul Național pentru Studierea Holocaustului din România "Elie Wiesel", http://www.inshr-ew.ro/ro/marturii/162-interviu-miriam-korber-bercovici.html
29. Interviu Solomon Rauth [Interview Solomon Rauth], Institutul Național pentru Studierea Holocaustului din România "Elie Wiesel", http://www.inshr-ew.ro/ro/marturii/220-interviu-solomon-rauth.html
30. Ioanid Radu, The Holocaust in Romania. The Destruction of Jews and Gypsies under the Antonescu Regime 1940-1944. With a Foreword by Elie Wiesel and a Preface by Paul A. Shapiro, Chicago, Ivan R. Dee Publishers, 2000, p. 39-79.
31. Ionescu Ștefan Cristian, "Californian" Colonists versus Local Profiteers?, in "Yad Vashem Studies", Jerusalem, Vol. 44, 2016, No. 2, p. 121-145.
32. Mircu Marius, Oameni de omenie în vremuri de neomenie [Humane People in Inhumane Times], București, Editura Hasefer, 1996, 243 p.
33. Olaru Dragoș, Scrisori din Transnistria (anul 1941) [Letters from Transnistria (1941)], http://hauster.de/data/DragosOlaru.pdf
34. Oliner Samuel P., Oliner Pearl M., The Altruistic Personality: Rescuers of Jews in Nazi Europe, New York, The Free Press, 1988, 419 p.
35. Popovici Traian, Spovedania. Biografie. Mărturii [The Confession. Biography. Testimonies]¸ edited by Dragoș Olaru, Serghei Voronțov, Cernăuți, Editura Rodovid, 2018, 156 p.
36. Purici Ștefan, Aspecte ale problemei minorităților naționale în Bucovina istorică între anii 1918 și 1940 (I) [Aspects of the National Minorities Issue in Historical Bukovina between 1918 and 1940 (I)], in "Analele Bucovinei", Vol. IV, 1997, No. 1, p. 131-144.
37. Rădulescu Mihai Sorin, Un nobil bucovinean la București și resuscitarea studiilor genealogice românești [A Bukovinian Nobleman in Bucharest and the Resuscitation of Romanian Genealogical Studies], în "Muzeul Național de Istorie a României", Vol. XVII, 2005, No. 1, p. 157-173.
38. Rozen Marcu, The Holocaust under the Antonescu Government. Historical and Statistical Data about Jews in Romania, 1940 - 1944, IVth Edition, revised and completed, Bucharest, 2006, 75 p. http://www.survivors-Romania.org/pdf_doc/the_holocaust_under_the_antonescu_government.pdf
39. Scurtu Ioan, Regimul de autoritate monarhică (februarie 1938 - septembrie 1940) [The Regime of Monarchical Autority (February 1938 - September 1940)], in Ioan Scurtu, Petre Otu (Eds.), Istoria românilor [The History of Romanians], Vol. VIII, România întregită (1918-1940) [The Reunited Romania], București, Editura Enciclopedică, 2003, p. 391-421.
40. Solidarity and Rescue in Romania, From the Report of the Elie Wiesel Commission, https://www.yadvashem.org/righteous/resources/solidarity-and-rescue-in-romania.html
41. Solonari Vladimir, Patterns of Violence. The Local Population and the Mass Murder of Jews in Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina, July-August 1941, in "Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History", Vol. 8, 2007, No. 4, p. 749-787.
42. Solonari Vladimir, The Treatment of the Jews of Bukovina by the Soviet and Romanian Administrations in 1940-1944, in "Holocaust and Modernity. Studies in Ukraine and the World", 2010, No. 2, p. 149-180.
43. Solonari Vladimir, Purificarea națiunii. Dislocări forțate de populație și epurări etnice în România lui Ion Antonescu: 1940-1944 [Purifying the Nation: Forced Population Displacement and Ethnic Cleansing in Romania of Ion Antonescu: 1940-1944], București, Editura Polirom, 2015, 424 p.
44. Suceava County Directorate of National Archives, Fund Prefectura județului Rădăuți [The Prefecture of Rădăuți County], F. 145/1941, f. 85, 127-128, 141, 147.
45. Székely Csaba István, The Holocaust of Memories, Miercurea Ciuc, Editura Alutus, 2011, 282 p.
46. Trașcă Ottmar, "Chestiunea evreiască" în documente militare române. 1941-1944 [The "Jewish Question" in Romanian Military Documents. 1941-1944], Iași, Editura Institutul European, 2010, 915 p.
47. Valenciuc Dumitru, Încă un uitat: dr. Simion Hîj [Another Forgotten: Dr. Simion Hîj], "Crai Nou", 10 august 2017, https://www.crainou.ro/2017/08/10/inca-un-uitat-dr-simion-hij/